It cast them away and embraced a creative direction that alienated one quarter of the audience, and deeply disappointed the majority who remained loyal. By clicking Post Your Answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. Someone making Season 4 clearly wants this to show to stop being 'Stargate SG1' and start being 'Stargate Jack and Sam' but I can't imagine *why* they did.
The biggest? In accordance with current regulations, it would be highly irregular for two serving officers such as O'Neill and Major Sam Carter [Amanda Tapping] to have an on-going personal relationship. Emboldened by your last mailbag, I have one question to askand after all these years, I promise it will be my last S/J question everhad we gotten the 3rd SG-1 movie, would the status of Sam and Jacks post-Threads relationship have been made clear?. 1) The Sam/Jack relationship was fraught with complications
AT: Id like to see some pay off for all their years together.
"Never.' It only takes a minute to sign up. They went through probably hundreds of loops and showed clips from a handful. Fans noticed the way the characters were drawn towards each other from the early seasons, and saw that play out fairly early as a what-if in aGroundhog Day-esque time loop-focused episode that saw Jack seize the moment in one of his many loops, to actually act on his feelings and kiss Sam.
And Mirror Carter was married to him.
This third season episode isnt important to shippers so much for what happens between Jack and Sam as it is for what happens when the two are apart. Why not watch one of the other hundreds of soap drama if you are interested in romance. After breaking off her engagement to Pete, its the moment of truth for Samantha Carter and her feelings for Colonel ONeill. Ive seen & read the same things and, as far as I am concerned, they are definitely together. And no matter what Captain Carter tries, the frozen Stargate will not dial out. With their fates evidently sealed, Sam gives up the fight and plays into Jacks delusion that she is his former wife, Sarah. Who needs an admission from the PTBs of their relationship when evidence like this is presented?. But that doesn't mean they weren't burying feelings.
Simlar to Dr. Carter saying For Crying Out Loud in PoV. And not in a negative way, she again gave that slightly smug, happy, and secretive smile like there was another reason she couldn't be with Orlin besides his age 7) When Martouf came from an AU, Sam almost kissed him, but pulled back at the last moment clearly relieved.
In another (the name of which eludes me), Jack and Sam are both questioned about the events of a certain mission, and both are found to be lying about those events. But as one loop draws toward its inevitable end, he decides to act on that forbidden love. By logging in to LiveJournal using a third-party service you accept LiveJournal's User agreement. And I don't even want to think about how long it's been since Jack and Daniel worked together the way they did in 'Pretense' or indeed were in any episode where they weren't either ideologically and/or physically separated. The creative shift in season four was little short of disastrous. "There was a line in the military, and there still is, where it would be completely inappropriate for there to be any real relationship. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. Then, theyll I find it interesting that you didn't finish the quote from Mallozzi's blog where he said: Where is the quote from Brad Wright from? "Bring in a new guard? It wasnt too much & overbearing, just a touch here and there so that it didnt make the show into a soap opera. Here we explain to them why and present some Stargate SG-1 Solutions. With only seconds left on the clock he hands General Hammond his resignation, and plants the biggest kiss on Sam that Stargate Command has ever seen. And although there were blips in the first season and a few sexist bits did still creep in, like the first meeting between Jack and Sam in 'Children of the Gods' and the unusually poor ending to 'The Broca Divide'; episodes like 'The Nox', 'The Torment of Tantalus', 'Fire & Water', 'Solitudes', 'Enigma', 'There But for the Grace of God' and 'Within The Serpent's Grasp' soon convinced me that this was a show which just got better and better with longer acquaintance. Jersey Shore), they were adults who focused on their adult lives and responsibilities, and most likely had something when they both got away from it all. GateWorld was founded in 1999, and is the Internets premiere destination for Stargate news and fandom. In this case, Dr. Samantha Carter comes through from an Earth recently conquered by the Goauld. @Paulster2 - Most writers never have any idea how to actually write a relationship, let alone how one develops.
Weve had a little bit of a shift around, introduced some new members to the creative team, welcomed Robert aboard in a different role as co-executive producer and confidence is high. What are the main differences between the original Stargate SG-1 and the Final Cut edition? Where Can I Watch Stargate Online in 2022? We are talking could-be relationships, right? The loss of that team relationship is the one I find the most upsetting. Im sure we can find volunteers to write the other gazillion pairings. Overall the audience for season four fell by 26%. on the cutting room floor when the episode ran long. As a depiction of two Air Force officers whose mutual respect and affection had deepened into friendship, the Jack and Sam relationship was terrific.
Why not? So with Jack eventually leaving Stargate Command to take another post, is the way clear for romance? If you watch the "groundhog day" episode (Window of Opportunity) at the end Daniel asks Jack if he ever took advantage of the situation. You just don't dissolve your feelings and your need for happiness because you 'decided' to be happy.
Its one scene and one scene only. Jack wouldn't have had to retire for them to have a relationship, he would just not have to be her commanding officer any more, which was taken care of when she moved to Atlantis. Sure. One of the writers (I want to say Mallozzi? I cannot comprehend why the production staff have pushed even harder down the same road.
They were so good at this.
It may not be up to me.". **grins** I never get tired of reading this list. Q. Okay. Because of course she's been giving him personal orders for years herself, he's just suddenly proud of the fact.
Create your free profile and get access to exclusive content. Jack tells her to Cmere and puts his arm around her.
Did Sauron suspect that the Ring would be destroyed? Here's a 9-episode viewer's guide for fans who always wanted Jack O'Neill and Samantha Carter to get together. The "World Series" quote is in Moebius (Season 8). How can I use parentheses when there are math parentheses inside? This despite the fact that those two very good actors cannot make their scenes together anything other than flat and uninspired because there is simply no chemistry between them. I swore I have seen that scene before. The same dynamic, the same focus and creative energy driving two characters to the exclusion of the others. On the eve of the signing of an historic alliance between Earth and the Tokra, one or both groups may have been infiltrated by a zatarc a Goauld-programmed assassin who doesnt even know he (or she) is working for the enemy. Have we ever seen a Stargate in the Ori galaxy or isn't there one at all? to confirm the McKay/Keller relationship in Atlantis? Sam says she's seeing a guy who works in Washington. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mj5YfnENYfY. Announcing the Stacks Editor Beta release! I feel it would have cheapened the show if they threw relationship drama in it. Great idea! I always have taken when two of the main characters start having romantic relationships in a series which didn't start out that way as. I have to admit that I was sceptical when I saw people on my forum talking about Jack and Sam beeing married, but after reading this I have to say I'm starting to turn around. It never happened and it was better that way. / Courtesy: Everett Collection. They are together, there is absolute no doubt about that. In the end, it turns out that Jack wouldn't leave Carter behind to die (or to somehow later escape on her own) because "he cared for her far more than is appropriate [for his position]", and he lied for that reason. Even Sam buying Frooties in Continuum points to their relationship. ", "When we first started the series, there was talk of starting up something between Jack and Sam, or Sam and Daniel, and we all nixed that," Tapping says.
When the chips are down (or in this case when Jack's subconscious is running the show) the only member of SG1 he remembers is Sam. Something which has been obvious since Jack and Sam's first meeting in 'Children of the Gods' -- making it all the more inexplicable that TPTB should have chosen to shine a spotlight on something they must have known would never be able to stand up to that degree of illumination. It started off strong, but the second half of the season really sucked. Do you want to see an acknowledgement of their relationship in the next movie? story spinning turns to the audiences desire for long-term, on-screen relationships to finally be paid off. Yes, they got together. For me, everything that once made 'Stargate' unique and admirable has been deliberately deconstructed in Season 4. I couldn't think -- still can't -- of any TV show that had a hero figure like Jack who showed such compassion and concern for all of his teammates irregardless of gender. Stack Exchange network consists of 180 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. I'd read about that scene, but it had never occurred to me to look for it. Sam gives a 'Jack' smile when reporting to Landry, a perfect example of her new-found happiness post S8:Compare this to pre-with-Jack angst: 5) When Sam explained to Barrett whey she took a desk job, which also seems OOC, she gave some goofy explanation about Cassie. But I can't even say the people making Season 4 have a hidden agenda because it's not even hidden.
(english is not my native language)So the writers argued if Sam and Jack are together or not? [beat] But I know him "One, y'know, which is more of a franchise big thing, is that Carter basically admits that she's having, she's in a relationship with O'Neill".
Unbeknownst to TPTB the little bones they occasionally throw us have formed a whole from which we can happily proclaimSam and Jack are TOGETHER!
If their ranks and their working relationship are ultimately what keep Sam and Jack apart, what happens when all of that is stripped away? Jack takes up pottery. Wait but wasn't Tapping character seeing what was his name Pete Shanahan? She also has a picture of Jack alone in her private quarters:Indicating a more personal relationship withhim.13) Though it was eventually deleted from the episode, a scene in SGA's S4 episode Trio clearly indicates Sam and Jack are in an ongoing relationship: -o-o-o-o-o-o-The reason I and many others assume they're married is varied. Oh yes and Teal'c stood around in the background with nothing to do, because that's usually the way those things go in TV land as well. Edit: Kudos to whupazz for finding the deleted scene. ", He continues, "If there was a real relationship, they would be separated. that he had to come back to sort out paper work for a number of things including the motorbike which we all know Sam rides, Metamorphosis: when Jack tells Sam to get some rest, she immediately leans into his shoulder. I watched Atlantis on Hulu, so maybe they included it. No copyright infringement intended.
I dont quite understand that, probably because of that I didnt mentioned it.
Keller: Retire, huh? Temperatures are dropping. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. And the bad episodes have been so *very* bad that it is difficult to know what to make of them. Why would "Cor-Ai" be earlier than "Singularity"? All rights recognised. You can sign up for a membership here. While every time Jack showed his respect for Sam by treating her like an Air Force officer instead of a woman, *my* respect for the show went up another notch. I think the beauty of the relationship between the four of us on the team is this great friendship that we have, and this wonderful respect and admiration for each other.
Stargate SG-1 :: Atlantis :: Universe Solutions. WATCH LIST: Will they or won't they? Or John Sheppard/Teyla Emmagan? I know Jack retired, and it was suggested that he did that so Sam and he could have a relationship. And he obviously has someone waiting for him at home, since he assumes all this coziness ;). Castle's been good, when they don't try to pump up drama. explains Wright. So an older man, eh? That's what she learned in Threads. If you make use of this list in your rewatch wed love to hear about it!
(And makes the loss of those scenes seem like such a dreadful waste.). given that he was her commanding officer. Get first access to never-before-seen videos, exclusive interviews, and much more!
Thanks by the resumen.
Is possible to extract the runtime version from WASM file? Pretty sure there's also a scene in SG-1 in S9 or 10 where Barret asks Sam if she's single now. "There were looks in dailies that we were picking up on," says co-creator Brad Wright tells SYFY WIRE of the pairing and how they came to be. How to explain mathematically 2.4 GHz and 5 GHz WiFi coverage and maximum range?
It makes for uneasy viewing. Were romantic feelings between Sam Carter and Jack O'Neill in Stargate SG-1 ever confirmed? Big Finishs Stargate Audio Dramas Are Up For Pre-order, Five Stargate Actors Who Are Coming To Dragon Con This Year, Report: Stargate and Star Trek Model Maker Eaglemoss Is In Financial Trouble. Also, people going into combat typically don't wait to marry for long because of the whole worry about imminent death thing.My friend Megyn made the following video based on this evidence: My Evidence that Sam and Jack are together, Big whoop for the reduction of spoiler-tags-which-there-is-no-point-in-m, As far as I'm concerned your theory is cannon. Its not for the elated look that Sam gives with the General shows up unannounced. 10)Sams PERSONAL directorys password is revealed as Fishing in LiS. Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. Teal'c has been woefully underused in almost every episode. There is no longer any sense of SG1 being a team.
Pursuing any sort of
We've told TPTB that we don't want the product they are trying to sell us. That look stays in the history books, because that is the loop when the cycle is finally broken.
Sams comment about being not exactly single, her password being fishing, having a pic of Sam and Jack fishing in her Atlantis office and another individual picture of Jack in her private quarters, plus of course, the deleted scene from Trio which pretty much confirms that they are in a relationship! I'm going to hang on in there until reruns start but if in the next five episodes there isn't at least one good original storyline where I see some clear evidence that the team dynamic is still intact and the Jack and Daniel relationship is still the heart of this show, I think I might just save myself that twelve dollars a month and watch videos from the days when 'Stargate' was about so much more than a man and a woman interacting their way unconvincingly through yet another dreary plot contrivance. Suspected of being a brainwashed by the Goauld, Jack and Sam both have to admit that they care about one another a lot more than theyre supposed to. The one with the blog) says that in his mind, they were together after season 8. @Darren can this be turned into a series perhaps? Now our Jack must handle the mission of freeing another reality from oppression, while Samantha is grieving the loss of his other self. True it was deleted, but it has to mean something: And then in the Stargate Atlantis legacy series of books (approved by MGM) that clearly hint that they are secretly in a relationship and the newest book, coming this summer, according to the author shall make that even clearer. It's the post-Threads evidence that Sam and Jack are together: The reason I KNOW Jack and Sam are together, anything TPTB might do to indicate otherwise being so OOC as to be IMPOSSIBLE for me to believe, is: 1) After the events of Threads/end-of-Moebius, Jack would be a complete lying jerk if he actually left Sam after promising he'd 'always' be there for her in response to her coming to him (and 8 years of watching them interact and their looks during the scene tell me he understood exactlywhy she was on his back deck). We already have two volunteers for the next chapters.
When Sam goes to run Atlantis in season 4, she's asked if she's in a relationship to which she replies "It's complicated". Jonathan Glassner, Executive Producer, Stargate SG-1 Seasons One - Three.
But a part of her never let go of that love that cannot be. When she found herself stranded, alone in a nebula on a deserted Prometheus (and with a head injury), Sam couldnt stop her mind from going there. However, due to military regulations and his position as her senior officer, neither character ever acted on their feelings during the show's 10-season run, though there were plenty of storylines that hinted at their feelings. Jacks retirement, but it was never made canon because, quite frankly, Ooh.
After 8 years of day-in-and-day out contact at work, she never picked up on that phrase, and still looked at him a bit oddly whenever he used it.
Where is this from - "She won't even let me go back to see the Cubs win the World Series" ??? "As for Carter and O'Neill, the writers constantly scan the Internet and they know the audience has a yearning to see some sexual attraction between these two characters, but at this time we believe that's too obvious a choice," explains Anderson.
Only UK viewers are witness to the ongoing attempts to minimise the loss of Daniel from the team. Wright's plans for his proposed newStargateserieswould see him not only bring back fan favorites like Sam specifically in her new role as general but also her science-minded colleague Daniel Jackson (Altered Carbon's Michael Shanks). Jack responds by staring at Carter and smiling, I doubt it was just for that kiss they showed us. The show wasn't stagnating. Join SYFY Insider to get access to exclusive videos and interviews, breaking news, sweepstakes, and more. Ill volunteer to do the Jack/Daniel one! In that respect, it laid down an important cornerstone for the extended shippy storyline to come in Season Four . But Jack refused to leave her behind the same thing he would do for anyone on his team, yes. The unique and incredible Jack and Daniel relationship, which was always the core of the show - and always should have been the core of the show in my opinion as it was the relationship from which the program originated - has apparently been discarded despite the incredible chemistry of the two actors which makes every scene they share so magical.
Way too much sexual tension for it not to pay off.
To which she kinda awkwardly replies "Not exactly". Do weekend days count as part of a vacation? Brad Wright, 2000, commenting on season 4.
Heck, you could even tell in the Stargate movie when they went to the ceremony to remove the last Ball Gould clone man, that there was nothing between them except friendship and mutual respect for each other. There are close friends, an Asgard transporter beam, and happily ever after. 
The Colonels leg is broken. Its not for an invisible Jack loitering in the womens locker room. Amanda Tapping in 1997, commenting on season 1.
Link your TV provider to stream movies, full episodes, and live TV.
it wasnt my call. Which brings us to 2) Jack and Sam could have gotten together after One thing that I actually like about the Stargate SG-1 series is the lack of melodrama (romance, etc). When I first started watching 'Stargate' I did so with great trepidation because I was dreading a set-up where 'that guy from MacGyver' hogged all the camera time, had a relationship with the blonde, and where O'Neill and Jackson were constantly at each other's throats, because after all, that's the way these things usually go in TV land. Ready to get your ship on? @BBlake I know. Unfortunately, it's pretty clear that OP is referred to the same source as the one in the answer above (from 2015). 
Romance may have never played a big part on Stargate SG-1, but the Sam-Jack Shippers have always been a vocal part of fandom. The characters are being changed to fit the writing, changed beyond recognition to accommodate the departure of one quarter of what was once a family.
Where was her comment about not exactly being single? So I find it pretty ridiculous that you would leave everything else aside and would try to fish out the fleeting glimpses of romance from what is supposed to be a sci-fi series. it was only natural that they should get together after the events of Jack, Sam, Daniel, and Tealc dont know who they are, but rather have had false identities imprinted onto their minds. Thanks for posting it where its easily accessible! It was implied in 'D&C' and now it's been made explicit in 'Beneath the Surface': the only relationship in 'Stargate' that now matters is the one between Jack and Sam. There was so much warmth in what 'Stargate' used to be; such a strong sense of characters who cared for one another so deeply, (shown over and over again in Sam's compassion for Jack in Solitudes; Jack's grief at the loss of Daniel in 'Fire & Water'; Jack comforting Sam in the same episode after she realizes they left Daniel behind; Jack forgiving and comforting Daniel in the storeroom scene in 'Need'; Teal'c mopping Jack's brow in 'Message In A Bottle'; Daniel's unstinting care of Jack in' The Fifth Race'; the look of absolute devastation on Jack's face when Teal'c is drowned in front of him in 'Demons' etc. Together to the very end.
Death Knell: after being rescued from the Kull Warrior, Sam just needs a moment to catch her breath. 11) In The Shroud, Sam and Jack are alone in her lab.
take it from there. I'm sure it will win new fans for itself as it has always done, but it is losing an awful lot of old fans in the process. In honor of Richard Dean Anderson and Amanda Tappings appearance together at Wales Comic Con this past weekend, were rounding up 10 of the shippiest episodes of Stargate SG-1.